creamy, sweet yogurt with all the fixins

so, at the expense of sounding like a jerk for tooting my own horn: i made my own yogurt. and that makes me awesome.

i had been obsessing over making yogurt for a few months now, nagging my husband (as i often do) about needing a yogurt maker. oh, our lives will be so much better with a yogurt maker. we will save hundreds of dollars! we will win the lottery, we will be happier in life and marriage if we have homemade yogurt at our disposal on a daily basis. our skin will glow, we will have increased energy, and a general lust for life. the usual naive excitement.

a yogurt maker is relatively inexpensive, starting around $40 for a decent model. the problem is that we are trying to afford a new home purchase right now, which costs a lot of money. needless to say, we are pinching pennies right now, and have even put off buying our meat grinder attachment for our kitchen-aid.

i was, however, lucky enough to inherit an unwanted ronco food dehydrator from a friend a few weeks ago. never used. what came with the “machine” was a “cookbook” with recipes ranging from beef jerkey to fruit roll-ups to yogurt. you’ve seen the infomercial.

now, i know what you’re thinking, and you’re right. what an stupid sounding way to make yogurt. don’t judge me. i was desperate.

and guess what? it freakin’ worked!

basically, in order to incubate, you’re just keeping your milk at a warm, steady temperature for a period of time, and the food dehydrator provides that environment. now, it isn’t a perfect machine, and it does get a little warm. so you’ll need to keep an eye on things. i also recommend doing this in a breezy area so the warm air circulates evenly about the inside of the machine.

my yogurt was delicious! i made 2 very successful batches, the first with a started from stonyfield farms organic full fat plain yogurt. i didn’t strain the first batch, but i did strain the second because brian likes greek style yogurt. i purchased the finest quality milk i could get my hands on here, which is full fat and barely pasteurized. i wish i could get raw milk here, but i can’t. i guess you could use 2% or some other type of milk, but why? fat is good for you. and it tastes wonderful. yes, it does look very involved and complicated, but hear me out. it’s deceptively easy. read the directions, follow the rules, and you’ll have easy and tasty yogurt.

i really loved the simple tart flavor of the dense, creamy yogurt. i can’t brag enough. i always stir in a little all fruit jam and some berries, and top it with nuts. this (besides a big-ass salad) is my favorite lunch, and a super healthy one, too. calcium, protein, fat, antioxidants, fiber, probiotic… what more does a body need?


4 cups good quality milk

2 tbsp good quality plain yogurt -do be sure it says it contains bacteria on the packaging, or it won’t culture

small jars with lids to put on the top shelf of your food dehydrator



first and foremost, be sure your jars are super-duper clean and dry. plug in your food dehydrator.

set your 2 tbsp of yogurt out on the counter-top in a big clean bowl to come up to room temp. i did this in a large pyrex for ease of pouring later on.

keeping a very close watch, bring your 4 cups of milk GENTLY up to 210f., just before it boils, keeping it well stirred. once it reaches 210f, turn the heat off. keep milk well stirred, and let milk cool to 112f.

slowly stir 112f milk into bowl with the room-temp yogurt. stir for a minute or so to be sure that everything mixes in nicely.

pour evenly into prepared jars, close them, and place in the top rack of the food dehydrator. incubate for 4-6 hours. check after 4 hours by gently agitating one of the jars to see if it has a yogurt-like consistency. it will be a little thin before you put it in the fridge.

i checked the yogurt during incubation after 4 hours by taking it’s temperature. once the temperature reached 116, i took them out and set them on the counter for half an hour to cool down a little. you want to keep them between 112-118 for this 4-6 hours, so do keep an eye on them during incubation.

once you are satisfied with your incubation time, stir all of the little yogurts into a large container. place yogurt into the fridge for a few hours. if the yogurt is too thin for your liking, you may strain with a cheesecloth for half an hour to an hour. if you do much longer than this, you will have cheese. so don’t get carried away.

oh, and note from my friend, josh: be sure that you don’t get carried away with stirring the yogurt. over-agitating will break the whey away from the yogurt, keeping it runny and strange. once you dump it over the cheesecloth, let it sit. resist pushing it through.


7 thoughts on “yogurt

  1. Hey Guys! Glad you are settling in in your new town!

    We also make yogurt, and you absolutely don’t need a machine. My dad always made his in the oven, and when we lived in Phoenix, we just put it on the porch! But here in Pittsburgh we use our Excalibur dehydrator to incubate it.

    And you are right, if you strain it too long it turns into cheese…yogurt cheese! But this can be a good thing. It’s like a lower fat cream cheese. You can spread it on toast or celery or things like that.

    We also sometimes whip it in the Kitchen Aid mixer with a little sugar to make it sweet and dessert-like (after it’s all incubated and yogurt-like).

  2. Pingback: Do you have to cook the beef to make beef jerky? | Make Jerky

  3. Hi Liz,

    Lynn shared your blog address with me (I met Lynn at a gardening class). I love your blog! Do you live in BG too? Or nearby? If so, you should check out Canal Junction Dairy–they’re known for their raw milk cheeses, but you can also join their raw milk club to get raw cow’s milk. Mostly, though, I just buy Calder Dairy’s products at Happy Badger.

    I’ve been making my own yogurt for a year now. I, too, wanted a yogurt maker, until I realized I could just put the yogurt in a quart jar and wrap my heating pad around the jar. It works great! The food dehydrator incubation is ingenious. What else do you use it for? I picked up a Ronco at a garage sale last fall and so far the only thing I’ve used it for is dried tomatoes.

    • hi sarah! i’ve peeked at your blog through lynn also! it’s nice to meet you. yes, i live in bowling green. i am currently buying dairy products at happy badger. they do have a few raw cheeses and butter, but no raw milk, just barely pasteurized. ohio makes stupid laws.
      i know you can make beef jerkey in the dehydrator, and also fruit roll-ups, banana chips, and candied dried ginger and other fruits. there is a little booklet full of recipes etc that i’d be happy to scan and email to you, if you wish. so far, i’ve only made yogurt with mine. i wish to do lots of experimenting after brian and i get settled in a little more.
      stay in touch! i’ll be reading your blog!

  4. Hey, just a comment. We get raw milk (for “pet food”, ha ha) from a local organic dairy. I also usually make our own yogurt, but I always pasturize the milk first. I’ll drink it raw, but on the stray chance that something harmful is in the milk, the last thing I want to do is incubate that bacteria and let it grow into somthing horrible. Maybe I’m wrong? Maybe the good bacteria kill off the bad? I know that is the case with aged cheese, but pretty sure it doesn’t work that way with fresh cheese, which yogurt essentially is. . .just my two cents worth.

  5. Hi Liz, I make my own yogurt too, three gallons at a time for my family of six.I only heat it to 180 f, cool it to 116 f, pour it into three gallon glass jars and put them in my oven over night.My oven has a pilot flame, so its warm.I also use gelatin, about one package per quart or three per gallon. Never fails.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s