peanut butter & chocolate pudding pie

peanut butter & chocolate pudding pie

i have the best friends in the world. -no, seriously. i know you think yours are pretty awesome, but mine are the BEST. i mean, the kind of friends that come from San Francisco to see you. the kind that spend the last change of their money on a food co-op membership for your birthday. the kind that secretly remember to send you a sweet and sappy card in the mail across the country (seriously spm, i needed it so badly!). the kind that buy you fancy gin, just because they want you to experience new flavors. the kind that spend a sunday night at a late night bbq just to catch up… mom & dad, you are included in this. thanks for putting up with my craziness! you are all amazing, and i want to thank everyone for making last weekend an incredible party. i don’t care if it was to see emily, or for my birthday, what a great day.

by the way, this is the last birthday that starts with a “2” for me.., so next year, i want an over the hill party. can you hire a grim reaper to show up instead of a clown? anyone know?

more loco than four loco

most of our parties end up in a bonfire. when we ran out of logs to burn, we ended up burning the famous “mural doors” that came with the house. -they had wisteria and fairies painted on them. burning these awful things…. ughh…. very theraputic.

i made this peanut butter & chocolate pudding pie for my birthday this weekend, and it was killer. we all know chocolate and peanut butter will make my heart melt, but this was surprisingly delicious. i whipped it together hours before the party, just winging it as i went along. why is it that the things i throw together turn out better than those that are calculated?

this pie is naturally sweetened with honey, not sugar, which is always amazing with peanut butter. the peanut cookie crust is lightly salted, which is a nice contrast with the sweetness that comes through the honeyed crust and, the filling of the pie. the crust is a little crumbly, a little crunchy, and super dreamy. it held the filling of the pie well. i was surprised at how well the filling set up, because the arrowroot worked like a charm. i am always a little skeptical with puddings, but this firmed up perfectly, even the peanut butter pudding. you could use cornstarch if you don’t have arrowroot powder.

yes, it did turn out a little lumpy. i was being impatient.

lesson learned: let it cool for 3 minutes before adding arrowroot powder.

still delicious and silky.

i can’t say much more about this pie other than that it is everything you imagine it will be.

lumpy love

favorite pie? yes.

make again? duh.

peanut butter & chocolate pudding pie

for the crust:

3 cups roasted & salted peanuts

1/4 cup peanut flour or coconut flour

1/2 tsp sea salt

1/2 tsp baking soda

4 tbsp oil

1/4 cup honey

2 tbsp vanilla extract


preheat oven to 350f.

combine vanilla, oil and honey in a bowl and set aside. grind peanuts in food processor until they make a crumbly meal. add in dry ingredients and pulse a few times. add wet ingredients, and mix in processor until thick dough forms. don’t over process, or it will turn into a liquidy peanut butter.

press dough into spring-form pan, or something where the bottom drops out. bake for 8-10 minutes, until it smells like a giant amazing cookie. it should appear golden brown, not too dark, or it will taste burnt. cool for an hour or more before filling.

chocolate pudding:

1 can coconut milk (14oz)

pinch of sea salt

3 tbsp honey

1 tbsp vanilla extract

1 cup dark chocolate chips

method: in saucepan, heat coconut milk and salt over medium. once it comes to gentle boil, remove from heat for 3 minutes. now sift in arrowroot powder and whisk vigorously. i like to use a hand mixer for the arrowroot step. it will thicken, and should be relatively smooth. whisk in honey and vanilla.

once combined, whisk in chocolate until it melts. whisk, whisk, whisk, then chill for an hour or so, along with peanut butter filling.

peanut butter pudding:

1 can coconut milk (14oz)

pinch of salt

3 tbsp arrowroot powder

1 cup smooth, no stir, natural peanut butter

1 tsp vanilla

method: in saucepan, heat coconut milk and salt over medium. once it comes to gentle boil, remove from heat for 3 minutes. now sift in arrowroot powder and whisk vigorously, again with a mixer if you have one. it will thicken, and should be relatively smooth. whisk in honey and vanilla.

finally, whisk in peanut butter until well combined and smooth. whisk, whisk, whisk, then chill for an hour or so.

chocolate pudding and peanut butter filling should cool at the same time.

to assemble:

fill pie by dropping heaping spoonful of pudding onto cooled shell. use a knife blade to swirl and marble. chill for at least 2 hours before serving. keep this pie cold, slice when cold, and serve cold.

i fully intended on serving this pie with bananas ice cream, but totally forgot by the time i was slicing, but i do know it would be an awesome addition.

ps, don’t forget about this:

click here to watch something wonderful!


11 thoughts on “peanut butter & chocolate pudding pie

  1. Happy belated birthday! What a gorgeous looking pie. And egg-free too. Perhaps I’ll make it for the Adopt A Gluten Free Blogger event this month. I signed up to adopt you last month but our move to Vegas turned into a bit of a nightmare and thwarted my plans. Happily, I’m on track for this month. Will let you know how my attempt to replicate this goes. All the best, Nicole

  2. You have great friends because you are awesome and are so great to us! Wish I was able to have you closer because I miss you every day. Thank you for hosting a wonderful summer bbq, delicious food, and amazing chocolate pie. YUM! So happy I was able to spend your birthday with you riding insane roller coasters and laughing like a bunch of teens.

  3. Pingback: Gluten-free peanut butter banana chocolate chip ice cream pie | SDC

  4. Hi, I love your site. Your photos are so fantastic and rustic looking! I’m in my home making your chocolate peanut butter mousse pie, and in the peanut butter sauce ingredients you mention a quarter cup of peanut or coconut flour. Could you explain how to incorporate that into the recipe? I think you might have overlooked it! Waiting to hear back from you,

    • yes! i’m so sorry, i must have missed that when i arranged the recipe, and put it in the wrong order.
      it was my mistake, and should be in the crust ingredients., not the peanut butter pudding!!!
      please review the recipe, as i have corrected it. i do hope it didn’t screw up your pie!
      i hope you let me know how it turned out!

  5. Hi, sorry for the long delay. I meant to write you sooner. The pie came out wonderfully. I did put the coconut flour in the peanut butter sauce. Oh well. But now I know. I had to give more than half of it away because I couldn’t stop eating it. It got dangerous! Tonight I will try making it with almonds and chocolate with an almond crust as well. What I like about your recipe is that it’s quite healthy. Can’t wait to try your cookies!! Thanks again

  6. It’s Mike again! Does the choc pudding need the same amount of arrowroot as the peanut sauce? Also, with the peanut sauce…how much honey do you reccommend? Thanks- Mike

    • mike-
      don’t worry about the questions! i’d rather you are comfortable with the recipe than be left with a question. the chocolate pudding requires no arrowroot powder to set up. it sets up really well on its own. the peanut butter pudding is the only filling here with arrowroot powder. i recommend starting with a tbsp or so of honey with the peanut butter pudding, and tasting to see if you want to add more. most shelf-stable peanut butters are already sweetened, so i found i didn’t need any. your tastes may be different from mine, though, so see what you think and add as you go along!
      thanks for the comments!

    • glad i could help!
      oh great. now i’m craving pudding again. crazy pregnant lady pudding cravings!
      stop by again! let me know if the recipe is what you were hoping for!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s